CDS I 2026Reading Comprehension
Cars, Cities and Contact with Nature

As the new century begins, it is becoming evident to urban dwellers, whether in industrial or developing countries, that there is an immanent conflict between the automobile and the city. Urban air pollution, often from automobiles, claims millions of lives. Congestion also takes a direct economic toll in rising costs in time and the use of petrol.

Another cost of cities that are devoted to cars is a psychological one, a deprivation of contact with the natural world — an “asphalt complex”. There is a growing body of evidence that there is an innate human need for contact with nature. Both ecologists and psychologists have been aware of this for some time. Ecologists, led by Harvard University biologist E.O. Wilson, have formulated the “biophilia hypothesis”, which argues that those who are deprived of contact with nature suffer psychologically and that this deprivation leads to a measurable decline in well-being.

Meanwhile psychologists have coined their own term — ecopsychology — in which they make the same argument. Theodore Roszak, a leader in this field, cites a study that documents humans’ dependence on nature by looking at the rate of recovery of patients in a hospital in Pennsylvania. Those whose rooms overlooked gardens with grass, trees, flowers, and birds recovered from illnesses more quickly than those who were in rooms overlooking the parking lot.

The “biophilia hypothesis”:

Answer और ExplanationAnswer and explanation

Answer: (C) Formulates that separation from nature leads to infelicitous mental states

Passage के अनुसार hypothesis argues that those who are deprived of contact with nature suffer psychologically है।
इसका अर्थ है कि प्रकृति से दूर रहने वाले मानसिक रूप से पीड़ित होते हैं, जो option (c) है।
Option (a) 'biological' शब्द के कारण लुभावना है, पर passage disorders को प्रकृति से वंचित होने से जोड़ता है, organisms से नहीं।
The passage says the hypothesis argues that those who are deprived of contact with nature suffer psychologically.
That means separation from nature leads to unhappy mental states, which is option (c).
Option (a) is tempting because of the word 'biological', but the passage links disorders to deprivation, not to organisms.

बाकी Options उत्तर क्यों नहीं हैंWhy the other options are not the answer

A'biological' शब्द देखकर यह विकल्प उचित प्रतीत हुआ। परंतु hypothesis का कारण जीव नहीं, प्रकृति से संपर्क का अभाव है।'Argues that psychological disorders are caused by biological organisms' picks up the word 'biological'; but the passage says those deprived of contact with nature suffer psychologically.
Bशहरी जीवन के उल्लेख से यह विकल्प प्रतीत हुआ। परंतु 'biophilia hypothesis' प्रयोग का डिज़ाइन नहीं है।'the design of a biological experiment which studies families that live in cities' mixes the word 'experiment' with city life; but the passage describes a hypothesis, not an experiment design.
Dप्रकृति और मनुष्य के संबंध की बात से यह विकल्प उचित प्रतीत हुआ। परंतु वह दर्शन की सामान्य परिभाषा है, जबकि passage का दावा विशिष्ट है।'a philosophy that studies humans in relation to natural phenomena' sounds like a broad definition; but the passage states a specific claim about mental distress when separated from nature.

Source: CDS I 2026। Solution: Prashant Sir, Ramban।Source: CDS I 2026. Solution by Prashant Sir, from Ramban.